How To Choose The Right Finish For Your Checkerboard Tiles

Retro-style diner floor with black-and-white matte checkerboard tiles illuminated by pink neon lighting, creating a vibrant and nostalgic atmosphere.

Recognized for their classic geometric patterns, checkerboard tiles have been a prominent choice in both residential and commercial spaces for decades. Their adaptability allows them to fit seamlessly into a variety of design aesthetics, from traditional to contemporary. However, choosing the right finish is essential to truly make the most of these tiles. The finish you select not only impacts the visual appeal but also influences the tile's durability, maintenance requirements, and how it integrates with the surrounding elements in the room.

In this guide, we will explore the different finishes available for checkerboard tiles and provide insights on choosing the best one for your space. By understanding the nuances of each finish—whether it's glossy, matte, polished, or satin—you can make a choice that enhances the beauty of your tiles while aligning with your practical needs and design preferences. Let’s dive into the details of these finishes and explore their unique characteristics to help you make the best choice for your space.

 

Retro-style diner floor with black-and-white matte checkerboard tiles illuminated by pink neon lighting, creating a vibrant and nostalgic atmosphere.

 

Understanding Checkerboard Tile Finishes 

Choosing the right finish for your checkerboard tiles is crucial in defining both the look and functionality of your space. Different finishes offer unique characteristics, affecting everything from the tile's visual appeal to its durability and ease of maintenance.


Glossy vs. Matte 

Glossy finishes are known for their high sheen and light-reflecting properties, which instantly bring brightness and sophistication to a room. They work particularly well in spaces that need an extra touch of glamour, such as formal dining rooms. The reflective quality of glossy tiles can make a space feel larger and more vibrant, making them an ideal choice for rooms with limited natural light. Additionally, glossy finishes tend to make colors appear more saturated, adding depth and contrast to the bold black-and-white checkerboard pattern.

However, it's important to keep in mind that glossy tiles can show smudges, fingerprints, and water spots more easily. This makes them better suited for lower-maintenance areas or spaces where they won’t be frequently exposed to dirt or moisture. They can also become slippery when wet, so they are best used for wall applications.

On the other hand, matte finishes offer a softer, more understated appearance. They don’t reflect light in the same way as glossy finishes, which can create a more intimate and calming atmosphere. This finish is well-suited for modern, minimalist, or industrial interiors where the focus is on simplicity and functionality. For example, the Leona 24x24 Matte Porcelain Tile in Amani Bronze, as shown in the photo, is an excellent option for those looking to add a warm, earthy tone to their space without overwhelming it with shine. Its matte surface hides smudges and fingerprints better, making it ideal for high-use areas or homes with children and pets, while its rich bronze hue adds depth and sophistication to any modern design.


Polished vs. Satin

In addition to glossy and matte finishes, polished and satin finishes also provide additional options that can redefine the look and feel of your space. Each offers a distinct texture and level of refinement, impacting both aesthetics and practicality.

Polished tiles are smooth and highly reflective, achieved through a mechanical process that buffs the surface to a mirror-like sheen. This creates a sleek and sophisticated look that instantly elevates any space, adding a luxurious and high-end feel to your room. The polished finish enhances the bold contrast of the checkerboard pattern, making it an eye-catching centerpiece that exudes elegance and refinement. However, while polished tiles are easier to clean due to their smooth surface, they do require regular maintenance to maintain their luster, as they can be more prone to scratches and stains. To address this, Edward Martin uses glazed porcelain and ceramic materials that are naturally resistant to scratches and stains, ensuring polished finishes remain both beautiful and practical over time.

Satin finishes, on the other hand, offer a soft, velvety look that strikes a balance between glossy and matte. This finish provides a smooth, refined texture without the intense reflection of polished tiles, making it a practical and stylish option for various spaces. Satin finishes work well in kitchens or hallways, as they bring a subtle glow while still being forgiving of minor scratches and smudges. They are a great choice for homeowners looking for a finish that combines elegance with durability, especially in areas that experience moderate use.

With surface treatments covered, it's time to consider how your design choices—whether traditional or modern—can further influence your finish selection.

 

Elegant hallway with grey-and-white polished marble look checkerboard tiles, large arched windows, and a glass door opening to a lush garden, creating a classic and airy atmosphere.

 

Considering Your Space and Design Aesthetic

Choosing the right finish for your checkerboard tiles goes beyond just aesthetics—it should harmonize with your space's overall design style and atmosphere. From traditional to contemporary interiors, the finish you select plays a crucial role in creating the desired look and feel of your room.


Traditional vs. Contemporary

Your design style plays a significant role in selecting the right finish for your checkerboard tiles. For traditional spaces, such as those inspired by Victorian or farmhouse aesthetics, polished finishes are a natural fit. Their gleaming surface enhances the intricate details and bold color palettes typical of traditional interiors. A polished checkerboard tile floor can also add a touch of elegance to any room, particularly when paired with ornate furnishings and warm, earthy tones. For example, the Leona 24x24 Polished Porcelain Tile in Nero Marquina, as depicted in the picture above, is an excellent option for those looking to create a sophisticated, timeless look. Its rich, deep black hue combined with the polished finish amplifies the elegance of a space, making it ideal for classic entryways, formal dining rooms, or luxurious bathrooms.

On the other hand, matte or satin finishes are ideal for contemporary spaces like mid-century modern, industrial, or Scandinavian interiors. These styles typically emphasize clean lines, neutral tones, and minimalist decor, all of which benefit from the subtle elegance of a matte finish. The understated look of a matte checkerboard floor can balance the striking contrast of black and white, creating a space that feels modern yet comfortable.

Ultimately, when choosing a finish, think about how it will interact with other elements in the room. A glossy finish might clash with matte furniture or surfaces, while a satin finish can provide a subtle sheen that softens the sharp contrasts often found in contemporary designs. By aligning the finish with your overall aesthetic, you ensure that your checkerboard tiles enhance the design rather than detract from it.


Light vs. Dark Spaces

Lighting can dramatically change the way your tile finish looks and feels. In rooms with ample natural light, such as living rooms or kitchens with large windows, polished finishes can make the space feel even brighter and more open. Their reflective quality helps bounce light around the room, creating a sense of airiness. This can be particularly beneficial in smaller rooms where you want to maximize the feeling of space.

In contrast, spaces with limited natural light, such as basements, narrow hallways, or windowless bathrooms, might not benefit as much from a polished finish. The reflection of artificial light could result in harsh glares that make the room feel uncomfortable. In such cases, a matte or satin finish would absorb light and create a more soothing and intimate atmosphere. These finishes work well in bedrooms, offices, or cozy reading nooks where a calmer environment is desired.

Additionally, when considering the color scheme of the room, darker tiles with a polished finish can help brighten up the space by reflecting light, while lighter tiles with a matte finish can create a more subdued and balanced feel. Understanding the interplay between light and finish will help you select the most suitable option for your space.

By aligning the finish with your overall aesthetic, you ensure that your checkerboard tiles enhance the design rather than detract from it. To further visualize how different finishes and designs will look in your space, Edward Martin offers an augmented reality (AR) tool. This innovative feature allows you to see your chosen tiles in real time, helping you make confident decisions that align with your vision and style.

With aesthetic factors covered, let's now shift our focus to the practical aspects of tile finishes, particularly in terms of durability and maintenance.

 

Cozy kitchen with beige cabinetry, black marble countertops, and blue-and-white matte checkerboard floor tiles, complemented by brass fixtures and rustic decor.

 

Functional Considerations

When selecting the right finish for your checkerboard tiles, it's important to think beyond aesthetics and consider how the tiles will perform in your space. Durability, wear resistance, and maintenance needs are key factors that will influence the longevity and practicality of your tiles.


Durability and Wear Resistance

To ensure your checkerboard tiles remain visually appealing and functional over time, it's crucial to choose a finish that offers the right balance of durability and wear resistance. The finish type significantly influences the tile's ability to withstand daily use, making it essential for maintaining its long-term appearance.

Satin finishes, with their soft sheen and smooth texture, are more resistant to scratches and imperfections, making them suitable for frequently used areas. On the other hand, glossy finishes, while visually striking, may be more prone to showing signs of wear, such as scratches, and are best for spaces where their reflective quality can be appreciated without heavy use.

Polished finishes provide a sleek, smooth surface that resists stains and moisture but may be vulnerable to scratches in frequently used areas. For example, in kitchens, entryways, or commercial spaces, polished tiles may need regular maintenance to maintain their shine. Using rugs or floor runners in these areas can help minimize wear.

Matte finishes, with their slightly rougher texture, are more forgiving of scratches and scuffs, making them an excellent option for family rooms, hallways, or outdoor patios. The Palmer 12x12 Matte Porcelain Tile in White (shown in the photo above) is a great example for those seeking a durable, minimalist look. Its non-slip, matte surface hides imperfections well, ensuring they maintain their appearance over time, even in active spaces.


Maintenance and Cleaning

The finish you choose for your checkerboard tiles can also significantly impact the maintenance effort required to keep them looking their best. Each finish has unique characteristics that influence cleaning frequency and techniques.

Polished checkerboard tiles, with their smooth, reflective surfaces, are easy to wipe down but can show smudges, fingerprints, and water spots more readily. Those made from porcelain, for instance, may require regular maintenance using a soft cloth and mild detergent, particularly in kitchens or bathrooms where these marks are common.

Glossy finishes applied in ceramic or porcelain materials also highlight smudges and spots but to a lesser extent than polished tiles. However, their light-reflecting properties mean that even small imperfections may be noticeable, necessitating frequent cleaning, especially in high-use areas. A microfiber cloth and gentle cleanser can help maintain their shine.

Satin finishes offer a soft sheen that masks smudges and dust effectively, making them suitable for areas that experience regular activity, like hallways and kitchens. The smoother texture compared to matte finishes allows for easier maintenance while still providing a refined look. Routine sweeping and mopping are enough to help keep them clean.

Matte finishes, with their understated texture, are the most tolerant when it comes to smudges and small particles, making them ideal for high-use areas. They typically require less frequent maintenance compared to polished or glossy checkerboard tiles, but periodic sweeping and mopping will help maintain their natural look. Deep cleaning may occasionally be needed to remove dirt buildup in the texture.

Establishing a regular cleaning routine based on your chosen finish will ensure that your checkerboard tiles remain attractive and well-maintained for years. It’s also essential to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for both tiles and grout to preserve their longevity and appearance.

Having covered maintenance and durability, it’s time to look at how personal style and budget can shape your final choice.

 

Refined entryway featuring grey and white polished checkerboard marble tiles, a plush bench, and a wooden staircase, creating a sophisticated and inviting atmosphere.

 

Personal Preferences and Budget

When choosing a finish for your checkerboard tiles, personal style and budget constraints play an important role in the decision-making process. Striking the right balance between aesthetic appeal and cost will help you create a space that reflects your vision without exceeding your budget.


Aesthetics and Style 

At the end of the day, your choice of finish should reflect your personal style and the atmosphere you want to create in your space. Glossy finishes can give your room a bold, modern look, while matte or satin finishes may offer a more subdued, natural feel. If you're drawn to a sleek, contemporary aesthetic, a polished finish might be the perfect way to bring a sense of luxury and sophistication to your space. For example, the Chantel 24x24 Polished Porcelain Tile in Imperial is an excellent option for those looking to create a high-end, polished look. Its deep, reflective surface and rich tones add an elegant touch, making it an ideal choice for luxurious living rooms, grand foyers, or upscale dining areas where a statement piece is desired.

On the other hand, if you prefer a more rustic or minimalist style, a matte or satin finish can help achieve a softer, more relaxed look. Matte finishes can work well in modern, industrial, or Scandinavian designs, where simplicity and functionality are key. By choosing the right finish, whether it's the sleek appeal of a polished tile or the subtlety of a matte surface, you ensure that your checkerboard tiles align with and enhance the overall aesthetic of your room.


Budget Constraints

Budget is an important consideration when selecting a checkerboard tile finish. Polished finishes generally cost more than matte finishes due to the extra processing required to achieve their mirror-like sheen. If you're working with a limited budget, matte finishes can provide an affordable yet stylish option that doesn't compromise on appearance. 

When considering your budget, it's also important to think about long-term costs. Polished finishes may require more upkeep to maintain their shine, while matte finishes can be easier to care for over time. By weighing the upfront cost against the maintenance requirements, you can choose a finish that fits both your budget and lifestyle.

 

Contemporary dining room with gray and white matte checkerboard marble tiles, arched windows, and a black table surrounded by brown chairs, offering a bright, modern vibe.

 

Making the Best Finish Choice for Your Checkerboard Tiles

Choosing the right finish for your checkerboard tiles is crucial to creating a beautiful and functional space. By considering your design style, lighting, durability, and maintenance needs, you can select a finish that complements your aesthetic while standing up to daily use. Whether you lean towards the sleek appeal of polished and glossy tiles or the understated elegance of matte or satin options, finding the perfect balance will ensure your checkerboard tiles remain a stunning feature in your home.

If you’re unsure which finish best suits your space, Edward Martin offers 4" x 4" samples that accurately reflect the color and finish of all tile sizes within each collection, providing a true representation of our premium products to help guide your decision. Explore our collections and request your sample today to begin transforming your space!

Reading next

Modern bathroom featuring a freestanding tub, a glass-enclosed shower with wood-textured tiles, and gold fixtures, with serene outdoor views.
Close-up of a black matte faucet against a backdrop of sleek, white marble tiles in a thin grout with subtle veining for a modern bathroom aesthetic.